We build. You grow.

Get best community software here

Start a social network, a fan-site, an education project with oxwall - free opensource community software

the need to isolate the forum posts that come from private groups [Passed to development team] | Forum

dave Leader
dave Oct 19 '13

This is a major issue as it underminds the need for privacy.   When someone creates a private group (and groups are attached to forum per group configuration in admin) those posts are sent over to the forum_post table.

 

The problem is that the forum_post table does not destingquish between forum posts and group post feeds, it just sticks them all in the table as the same.  There is no field in the table which allows and way to know where that post came from other than topicId. 

 

This is a concern because any plugin that pulls from the forum_post table will show any and all posts to everyone on the site.  Those posts were originally private and should remain so.

 

Solution...   add a table field to forum_post table called topsecet (or whatever you want to call it)  it should be an enum '0','1'   and should default to 0

 

when a private group post is added to the forum_post table it should make that field (topsecret) a 1  

 

when any plugin sees that 1 it should not pull that content unless the plugin pulling that content is the originating group topidId. 

 

you might also really consider adding even another field for group number so that any plugin will have two data fields to check for validity in data process (two checks are better than one) 

 

thanks..

 

Or there needs to be an array build of all topicId or group Id that are set to private and anything pulled from the forum_post table (or newsfeed table for that matter as well)  needs to be filtered thru that array.

 

i have attached an image..

 

 

 

thanks

The Forum post is edited by Alia Oct 22 '13
Alia Team
Alia Oct 21 '13
Dave, thanks for one more excellent report and a solution to it.
I have passed this over to development team.
dave Leader
dave Oct 21 '13
:) thanks Aliia and welcome back
Martyn ZombieTuesday
I am having this issue on my site, has a fix been found for this .. or can anyone help please?


Karalius Kraujas
Karalius Kraujas Jun 11 '14
yeah... whats the point of private group if anyone can see forum posts?????
ross Team
ross Jun 11 '14
Yes, that already has been reported and our developers will take care of it. 
Karalius Kraujas
Karalius Kraujas Jun 29 '14
awesome:)


Jochen
Jochen Jul 2 '14
maybe the use of the free privacy plugin helps ?  br, Jochen
Sibirskiy
Sibirskiy Dec 23 '14
Any updates on this, this is critical
more than a year and the issue still exists ? please pay some attention !!!
ross Team
ross Dec 29 '14
Yes, the issue will be addressed in the nearest future. 

Oxwall is a small team, we have our own roadmap, which we have to stick to. We do our best to fulfill the needs of our clients. Thank you for your patience, guys. 

Sibirskiy
Sibirskiy Jan 2 '15

Quote from ross Yes, the issue will be addressed in the nearest future. 

Oxwall is a small team, we have our own roadmap, which we have to stick to. We do our best to fulfill the needs of our clients. Thank you for your patience, guys. 



Thanks, I understand
Good luck
Jordi
Jordi May 11 '15
is this fixed?
ross Team
ross May 11 '15
No, it's not yet. 
Jordi
Jordi May 12 '15
ok thanks ross... is there a alternative to communicate in a private group? because this makes a private group a but useless .
ross Team
ross May 12 '15
a user can close his/her profile newsfeedfor everyone in the privacy plugin configuration, this is the only solution for now. 
Jordi
Jordi May 12 '15
hmmm that is not a good option. is the oxwall team working on this?
ross Team
ross May 12 '15
it's been reported. wait for the fix please then
Jordi
Jordi May 12 '15
ok i will. 
Jordi
Jordi Jul 22 '15
Hi Ross, is there any news on this problem? I think its very important to get the groups working like the should. 


Thanks

ross Team
ross Jul 22 '15
No yet, I'll keep you updated in this post or via PM
Pages: 1 2 »