I found the solution to the issue I was having. When you save a .csv file from Excell on a Mac it does not place the end of line indicators correctly. I imported my data into a Google Doc Spreadsheet and then exported a .csv file, which worked correctly.
I also needed to scroll down on the import tool field options to see all of them. They are as follows:
About, About My Match, Birthday, Body Type, Body Type, Drinking, Drinking, Email, Ethnicity, Ethnicity, Eye Color, Favorite Way to Spend Time, Favorite Way to Spend Time, Gender, Hair Color, Here For, In My Own Words, Looking For, Match's Desired Age, Password, Real Name, Should Search For, Smoking, Smoking, Username